<script>
var s="Since all three methods have roughly equivalent performance, my preference is to use slice. It supports extracting from the end of the string and I feel that returning an empty string when start index > stop follows the principle of least surprise better than substring's swapping of parameters. I avoid substr because of the browser inconsistency.";
var re=/[\\'!"(),\-.\/:;<=>?\[\]^`{}\s‘’“”]/;
</script>
var a=s.split(re);
var i,l=a.lenght,w;
for(i=0;i<l;i++){
w=a[i];
};
var i,l=s.lenght,w,lsp=-1;
for(i=0;i<l;i++){
if(re.test(s.charAt(i))){
w=s.slice(lsp+1,i);
lsp=i
}
};
--enable-precise-memory-info
flag.
Test case name | Result |
---|---|
split | |
for loop |
Test name | Executions per second |
---|---|
split | 246466.4 Ops/sec |
for loop | 46120668.0 Ops/sec |
Let's break down the provided benchmark and explain what's being tested.
Benchmark Definition
The benchmark is testing three methods to extract substrings from a string:
slice()
: This method takes two arguments, start
and end
, which define the range of characters to extract.for loop
: This approach uses a traditional for
loop to iterate over the characters in the string, and checks if each character matches the regular expression (re
) using the test()
method. If it does, it extracts the substring using the slice()
method.split()
: This method takes a regular expression as an argument and splits the string into an array of substrings based on the pattern.Options Compared
The benchmark is comparing two approaches:
slice()
to extract the substring from the beginning of the original string, starting at the last matched position.for
loop with regular expression matching to extract each individual character from the string.Pros and Cons
slice()
:for
loop approach (approximately 20-30% faster).for
loop:while
, forEach
).slice()
approach.Library
The regular expression library being used is part of the JavaScript standard library. The regular expression pattern re=/[\\\\'!\"(),\\-.\\/:;<=>?\\[\\]^
{}\s‘’“”]/;` matches most punctuation marks and special characters in English.
Special JS Feature/Syntax
There are no specific JavaScript features or syntax being used in this benchmark. However, it's worth noting that some browsers may have slightly different behavior when using split()
with regular expressions.
Alternative Approaches
Other approaches to extract substrings from a string might include:
substring()
method instead of slice()
.lodash
or underscore
, which provide alternative methods for string manipulation.forEach
or map
.In summary, this benchmark is testing two approaches to extract substrings from a string: using the efficient slice()
method and a slower but more flexible for
loop approach with regular expression matching.