var string = "I am the god of hellfire, and I bring you..."
var substring = string.slice(17, 25);
var substring = string.substring(17, 25);
var substring = string.substr(17, 25);
var substring = string.split(',')[1];
--enable-precise-memory-info
flag.
Test case name | Result |
---|---|
slice | |
substring | |
substr | |
split |
Test name | Executions per second |
---|---|
slice | 2248180992.0 Ops/sec |
substring | 2192115712.0 Ops/sec |
substr | 2321874432.0 Ops/sec |
split | 13598420.0 Ops/sec |
Let's break down the provided JSON data and explain what's being tested.
Benchmark Definition
The benchmark is designed to compare the performance of four string manipulation methods:
substring()
substr()
slice()
split()
(specifically, splitting a comma-separated string)Options Compared
Each test case compares two options for creating a substring or split string.
substring()
, the comparison is between string.substring(17, 25)
and string.slice(17, 25)
.substr()
, the comparison is between string.substr(17, 25)
and string.slice(17, 25)
.split()
, the comparison is between string.split(',')[1]
and no alternative (i.e., just using string
as a single value).Pros and Cons of Different Approaches
Here's a brief overview of each approach:
substring()
: This method returns a new string containing a section of the original string. It's generally considered the most readable and maintainable option among the four.substr()
: This method is similar to substring()
, but it's less commonly used in modern JavaScript. It returns a new string containing a section of the original string, starting from the offset specified by the second argument.substring()
, but can be slightly faster due to its native implementation.substring()
, less commonly used in modern JavaScript.slice()
: This method returns a new array containing a section of the original string. When used with two arguments, it returns an array containing one element (a substring). It's generally faster than substring()
for large substrings.substring()
, can be confusing when used with arrays.split()
: This method splits a string into an array of substrings based on a specified separator. When using only one argument, it returns the entire string if it doesn't contain the separator.Library
The split()
method uses the built-in JavaScript String.prototype.split()
method. This method is implemented in native code, making it fast and efficient.
Special JS Feature/Syntax
There are no special features or syntaxes used in this benchmark that would require additional explanation.
Other Considerations
When choosing between these string manipulation methods, consider the following factors:
substring()
for its clear purpose and readability.slice()
for large substrings due to its native implementation and efficiency.split()
when working with comma-separated strings or arrays.Alternatives
Some alternative string manipulation methods you might consider include:
slice()
, substr()
, and indexOf()
, which can be useful when working with arrays or strings in a more functional programming style.