Benchmark: Split+join vs replace vs replaceAll long string

Script Preparation code:

var example = 'Example 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Examplxample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4e 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4'

AخA
 
var example = 'Example 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Examplxample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4xample 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4e 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4'

Tests:

split + join
var result = example.split(',,;').join('; ');
var result = example.split(',,;').join('; ');
replace
var result = example.replace(/,,;/g, '; ')
var result = example.replace(/,,;/g, '; ')
replaceAll
var result = example.replaceAll(',,;', '; ')
var result = example.replaceAll(',,;', '; ')

Rendered benchmark preparation results:

Suite status: <idle, ready to run>

Previous results

Experimental features:

Memory measurements supported only in Chrome.
For precise memory measurements Chrome must be launched with --enable-precise-memory-info flag.
More information: Monitoring JavaScript Memory

Test case name	Result
split + join
replace
replaceAll

Fastest: N/A

Slowest: N/A

Latest run results:

Run details: (Test run date: 2 months ago)

User agent: Mozilla/5.0 (Macintosh; Intel Mac OS X 10_15_7) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/131.0.0.0 Safari/537.36

Browser/OS: Chrome 131 on Mac OS X 10.15.7

View result in a separate tab

Test name	Executions per second
split + join	350291.8 Ops/sec
replace	225883.7 Ops/sec
replaceAll	221231.6 Ops/sec

Autogenerated LLM Summary (model llama3.2:3b, generated 7 months ago):

To answer this question, I will focus on the code snippets that are actually provided.

Looking at the Html Preparation Code section, I see that there is an example string:

example = ",;Example 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4"

This string appears to contain semicolons (;) and commas (,), which are separated by semicolons.

Now, let's look at the individual test cases. There are three test cases:

Test Case 1: split + join

var result = example.split(',,;').join('; ');

This code splits the input string into an array of substrings using commas and semicolons as separators, and then joins the resulting array back into a single string with semicolons in between.

Test Case 2: replace

var result = example.replace(/,,;/g, '; ');

This code uses a regular expression to replace all occurrences of the pattern ,,; with a single semicolon (;) in the input string.

Test Case 3: replaceAll (not shown)

This test case is not complete, as the replacement string is missing.

To answer the question, I would need more information about the expected output or behavior for each test case. Can you please provide that?

LLMs can make mistakes. Check important info.

To answer this question, I will focus on the code snippets that are actually provided.

Looking at the `Html Preparation Code` section, I see that there is an example string:
```
example = ",;Example 1,,;Example 2,,;Example 3,,;Example 4"
```
This string appears to contain semicolons (`;`) and commas (`,`), which are separated by semicolons.

Now, let's look at the individual test cases. There are three test cases:

**Test Case 1: `split + join`**
```javascript
var result = example.split(',,;').join('; ');
```
This code splits the input string into an array of substrings using commas and semicolons as separators, and then joins the resulting array back into a single string with semicolons in between.

**Test Case 2: `replace`**
```javascript
var result = example.replace(/,,;/g, '; ');
```
This code uses a regular expression to replace all occurrences of the pattern `,,;` with a single semicolon (`;`) in the input string.

**Test Case 3: `replaceAll` (not shown)**

This test case is not complete, as the replacement string is missing.

To answer the question, I would need more information about the expected output or behavior for each test case. Can you please provide that?

Related benchmarks:

Split+join vs replace vs replaceAll long string (version: 0)

Comparing performance of: split + join vs replace vs replaceAll

Created: 2 years ago by: Guest

Jump to the latest result

split + join

replace

replaceAll

Suite status: <idle, ready to run>

Experimental features:

Fastest: N/A

Slowest: N/A

Autogenerated LLM Summary (model llama3.2:3b, generated 7 months ago):